top of page

THE ROAR OR THE GROWL: A QUESTION OF NATIONAL PRIDE

By P Mohan Chandran


What truly captures the essence of a nation? Is it the symbol that appears most frequently on its emblems, or the one that resides most densely in its wild expanses? Does it revolve around the metaphorical strength symbolized by a creature, or the diversity represented by its widespread existence? India currently grapples with this conundrum – a royal tug-of-war between the lion and the tiger.


A shift is palpable on the horizons of India's national identity. Whispers echo through the corridors of power, hinting at a potential transition of the mantle of National Animal. A transition that could dethrone the revered tiger, a symbol of India's wild strength since 1972, and crown the majestic lion instead. Is this an audacious revamp, a mere political whim, or a reflection of a deeper narrative?


The spark for this national debate was ignited by a proposal from Rajya Sabha MP Parimal Nathwani. The environment ministry took the bait, pitching the proposal to the National Board for Wild Life (NBWL). An interesting twist is that the backing came from members deeply rooted in Gujarat, a state that takes immense pride in being the sole shelter for the Asiatic Lion. With a population of 411, the lion in Gujarat is a symbol of regional pride, a sentiment now seemingly expanding to national proportions.


In stark contrast, the tiger, with its awe-inspiring stripes and regal demeanor, freely roams across 17 states in India. A testament to the richness of India's biodiversity, their population now stands at 2,200, an accomplishment attributed to relentless 'save the tiger' campaigns. One might argue that such a widespread existence lends the tiger a stronger claim to the title of the National Animal. Isn't it reflective of India's diverse yet unified identity?


Yet, the symbolism surrounding the lion is hard to overlook. The lion, embodied in Prime Minister Narendra Modi's 'Make in India' campaign, represents a vision of a new, robust India. Further, the 2022 refurbished National Emblem, now presiding over the Parliament building, features lions in full roar. It seems that lions are gradually clawing their way to the heart of India's national identity.


Critics, however, see another perspective. They perceive this move as a possible green light for industrial projects near tiger sanctuaries. A clever, strategic ploy, they opine, could risk the sanctity of the tiger's natural habitat.


So, we return to our contemplation – the growl of the tiger or the roar of the lion? Which resonates more with India's national pride? Is it about honoring the widespread existence of the tiger that embodies India's diversity, or is it about glorifying the lion that symbolizes the strength of a resurgent nation?


These are questions for us to ponder upon, as India stands at the crossroads of a defining decision. The choice we make might alter more than just our national emblem. It might redefine our perception of national pride and identity. So, ask yourself, in this narrative of national pride, which story resonates more with your vision of India – the tiger's growl or the lion's roar?


Do you agree that Lion should be made the National Animal of India instead of the Tiger?

  • Yes, Lion is more royal and powerful than a tiger.

  • No, Tiger aptly encapsulates the essence of India.



© 2023. P Mohan Chandran. All Rights Reserved.

07072023

Comments


bottom of page